Brethren Christian was playing in its first Southern Section final.
St. Margaret's, in a CIF final for the seventh time in 11 years under head coach Susie Maga, rolled in the opening game to set the tone for the rest of the match. The Tartans were never really threatened, although Brethren Christian made things interesting in both the second and third games.
The teams were knotted at 9-9 in the second game when the Tartans went on a 6-0 run to assume control. They eventually built the lead to as much as eight points (21-14) and came away with a 25-18 win.
In the third game, the Warriors rallied from a 9-4 deficit to tie the score at 11-11. But consecutive kills by senior middle blocker Erika Page, started another 6-0 run by the Tartans that allowed them to go in front, 17-11. A block at the net by Warriors' junior middle blocker Meghan Haney ended the run.
St. Margaret's took the match on kill by junior setter Emily Moore to clinch a 25-14 victory.
Despite the loss, Brethren Christian will join St. Margaret's in next week's state playoffs. Daugherty said the Warriors will play a first-round match on the road "either Monday or Tuesday."
To reach the Division IV-AA final, Brethren Christian swept Buckley (Liberty League No. 2), then Sunkist League champ Patriot, and in the quarterfinals, upset Condor League champion and second seed Laguna Blanca in three games. The Warriors then took down Camino Real champ Serra in four games in the semifinals to reach Cypress.
"We were very much underdogs all the way through," said opposite Rebekah Rudd, one of four seniors on the Brethren Christian squad and co-captain along with senior outside hitter Randi Braak. "We were a little nervous at first but we were nervous because we were anticipating this [match]. It's a sad ending but a good experience."
"I'm very proud of my team for getting this far," said Daugherty, who is in her first year as coach of the Warriors. "We didn't play as well as we could have but my girls really are Warriors and they fought to the end. I'm very blessed to be coach of this team."